P0
π Lehi Condo β HOA Lawsuit Response (Case #269402169)
$2,437.81+ outstanding Β· 18% interest Β· Lien recorded 11/4/2025 Β· Contact HOA attorney TODAY
| Property | Type | Tenant / Platform | Rent | Mortgage | Entity | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Lehi Condo β Timp Point B303
1985 N 3330 W, Unit B303, Lehi, UT 84043
Access codes: stored in vault
|
STRβLTR 3BR/2BA Β· 1,300 sqft Built 2022 |
Previously Airbnb Now long-term rental |
$2,269 net/yr
2024: $30,647 gross
Bennett 50%: $1,134
|
HOA: $219/mo
($163 + $56 utility)
|
LM Real Estate LLC
50% Bennett Β· 50% S. Loveland
|
π΄ CRITICAL | 3 active legal/insurance violations |
|
Provo Duplex
280 N 900 W, Provo, UT 84601
|
Duplex Room rentals |
Multi-tenant Rentler platform |
$400β$580/room
+utilities + WiFi
|
TBD |
Saratoga Springs One LLC
50% Bennett Β· 50% Brad Maxwell
|
β οΈ GAP | No legal docs on file |
|
NSL Chidester
1052 Chidester Dr, North Salt Lake, UT 84054
Access codes: stored in vault
|
SFR Single family Β· 2-car garage Built 2007 |
Arnold Mataese Fixed lease β Nov 2026 via Rentler Β· cooperative |
$2,600/mo
+sewer added to rent
|
~$1,998/mo
Truist Mortgage
Bal: ~$333,521 (Apr 2026)
|
Chidester Real Estate LLC
50% Bennett Β· 50% Gretta Maxwell
|
β Occupied |
Equity: ~$106K total Β· Bennett: $53,242
MV: $483Kβ$551K Β· FSBO option: $549β$555K
Prior agent: Duane (5β6%) Β· FSBO saves ~$18β23K
9 deferred maintenance items open
|
|
Pleasant Grove (Mom's House)
58 S 850 E, Pleasant Grove, UT 84062
|
SFR Up/Down split |
Gretta Maxwell (upstairs) Basement: VACANT (since Jul 2025) Rocky Mtn Power + Gas autopay |
$1,500/mo
Upstairs only (was $750 JunβSep '25)
Basement: $0 (was $1,750/mo)
~$17,500 lost (10 mo vacant)
|
TBD |
Bennett Maxwell
Co-managed w/ Gretta
|
β οΈ Part Vacant |
Bennett paid $4K (Jul '25) + $1K (Feb '26)
List basement NOW at $1,750/mo
Prior basement tenant: Jezebel (left Jul 10, 2025)
Security deposit: $1,750 β refunded $1,425
|
|
Lehi Townhome β Willow Point
2032 N 3830 West, Lehi, UT 84043
|
VACANT 5BR/3.5BA Β· 2,280 sqft LTR only (HOA bans STR) |
VACANT since March 2026 Prior tenants left without paying Mar rent Security deposit held for March |
$0/mo (vacant)
Was: LTR Β· Break-even: $2,900/mo
HOA PROHIBITS STR β LTR only (6+ mo lease)
|
Break-even: ~$2,900/mo
Negative cash flow NOW
|
TBD
Entity TBD
|
π΄ VACANT |
560 sqft carpet β cat urine level 7
$4,200β$5,700 remediation needed first
Not furnished Β· HOA: 6+ mo lease minimum
Appliances: Electrolux W/D Β· GE fridge Β· Amana stove
|
| Contractor | Website | Specialty | Est. Cost Range | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P.O.R.S. (Pet Odor Removal Service) | petodorremovalservice.com | Pet odor / subfloor | $4,200β$5,700 | Quote Needed |
| Power Plus Cleaning | Local Utah |
Carpet / remediation | $4,200β$5,700 | Quote Needed |
| Pure Flow Clean | Local Utah |
Carpet / subfloor | $4,200β$5,700 | Quote Needed |
| Contact | Role | Property | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ron Haslam | HOA Attorney (Heidlaw) | Lehi Condo B303 | CALL TODAY |
| Garrett Brown | HOA Attorney (Heidlaw) | Lehi Condo B303 | MSJ Response |
| Arnold Mataese | Tenant | NSL Chidester | Cooperative Β· via Rentler |
| Gretta Maxwell | 50% Co-owner | NSL Chidester Β· PG Mom | Co-managed |
| Stephen Loveland | 50% Co-owner | Lehi Condo B303 | LM Real Estate LLC |
| Brad Maxwell | 50% Co-owner | Provo Duplex | Saratoga Springs One LLC |
| Rentler Platform | Rent collection | NSL Chidester Β· Provo | rentler.com |
| Property | Annual Gross | Annual Expenses | Net Income | Bennett 50% | Market Value | Loan Balance | Equity (Bennett) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lehi Condo (B303) | $30,647 | $28,378 | $2,269 | $1,134 | TBD | TBD | Lien risk |
| Provo Duplex | ~$28,800 est. | TBD | TBD | 50% Bennett | TBD | TBD | TBD |
| NSL Chidester | $31,200/yr | ~$23,976/yr | ~$7,224/yr | ~$3,612 | $483Kβ$551K | ~$333,521 Apr 2026 | ~$53,242 |
| Pleasant Grove (Mom) | $18,000/yr +$0 (bsmt vacant) | TBD | Lost: $21K/yr | 100% Bennett | TBD | TBD | TBD |
| Lehi Townhome LTR ONLY | $0 (VACANT since Mar 2026) | $34,800/yr ($2,900/mo) | -$2,900/mo bleeding | TBD | TBD | TBD | TBD |
| CURRENT PORTFOLIO (2 vacancies) | ~$67,200/yr actual | ~$100β$104K/yr | -$3,100/mo (net) | $53K+ (NSL only) | |||
| FULL OCCUPANCY TARGET | ~$108Kβ$112K/yr | ~$100β$104K/yr | +$1,500β$3,000/mo | $53K+ confirmed |
| Property | Rent In | Mortgage Out | Net |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lehi Condo B303 | LTR pending | ~$1,500 | - |
| Provo Duplex | ~$2,400 | TBD | +est. |
| NSL Chidester | $2,600 | $1,998 | +$602 |
| PG Mom (upstairs) | $1,500 | ~$800 est. | +$700 |
| PG Basement | $0 (VACANT) | β | -$1,750 lost |
| Lehi Townhome | $0 (VACANT) | ~$2,900 | -$2,900 |
| TOTAL (now) | ~$6,500 | ~$7,200 | ~-$700 to -$3,100 |
| FULL OCCUPANCY | ~$11,150 | ~$7,200 | +$3,950 |
| Task | Property | Owner | Priority | Status | Due | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contact HOA attorney β Case #269402169 | Lehi Condo B303 | Bennett | P0 | OVERDUE | NOW | |
| List PG basement at $1,750/mo β VACANT 11+ months Β· $19,250 lost | Pleasant Grove | Bennett / Rachel | P0 | ACT NOW | TODAY | |
| Satisfy HOA lien β $2,437.81 + 18% interest | Lehi Condo B303 | Bennett + Stephen | P0 | OVERDUE | NOW | |
| Bind HO-6 insurance β get quote + send cert to lender | Lehi Condo B303 | Bennett | P0 | OVERDUE | NOW | |
| Respond to HOA in writing β CC&R violations / $850+ fines | Lehi Condo B303 | Bennett | P0 | In Progress | ASAP | |
| Get 3 contractor quotes β Lehi Townhome carpet remediation | Lehi Townhome STR | Rachel / Bennett | P1 | Pending | This week | |
| Complete carpet/subfloor remediation (560 sqft) | Lehi Townhome STR | Contractor | P1 | Blocked (quote) | TBD | |
| List Lehi Townhome as LTR at $2,900+/mo β HOA prohibits STR | Lehi Townhome (LTR) | Bennett / Rachel | P1 | Post carpet fix | 30-45 days | |
| Address 9 maintenance items β Arnold Mataese | NSL Chidester | Rachel / Contractor | P2 | Scheduled | Next 30 days | |
| Gather legal docs for Provo Duplex entity | Provo Duplex | Bennett + Brad | P2 | Pending | 30 days | |
| Evaluate FSBO option β NSL Chidester | NSL Chidester | Bennett | P2 | Under Review | Q3 2026 | |
| Fill ~4 property records in Rachel Notion DB | All | Bennett | P2 | Pending | This week | |
| Wire Gmail + GHL SMS β Rachel Phase 2 | All | Rachel/Leo | P3 | Phase 2 | Next sprint |